Past Presidents
| 2023 | Dennis Walker | Green Township |
| 2022 | Esad "Steve" Kucevic | Hopatcong |
| 2020 - 2021 | Michael Donahue | Stanhope |
| 2019 | James Raperto Sr. | Franklin |
| 2018 | Jessica Casella | Andover Borough |
| 2017 | Anthony Frato Sr. | Branchville |
| 2016 | Michael Clark | Sussex |
| 2015 | Scott Verkon | Newton |
| 2014 | Ryan Riegel | Montague Township |
| 2013 | Cheryl (Delea) Thom | Sandyston Township |
| 2012 | Daniel Scheuer | Ogdensburg |
| 2011 | Ben Cosh | Wantage Township |
| 2010 | Virgil Rome, Jr. | Fredon Township |
| 2009 | Joseph Sugar | Stillwater |
| 2008 | Charles "Chuck" Konecke | Frankford Township |
| 2007 | John Blackford | Lafayette |
| 2006 | Charles McMickle | Hamburg |
| 2005 | Anthony Wallace | Highland Lakes |
| 2004 | Alan Nagle | Vernon |
| 2003 | James Sheridan | Pochuck Valley |
| 2002 | Thomas Rider | Sparta |
| 2001 | Margaret "Meg" Seesselberg | Byram Township |
| 2000 | William "Billy" Pierce | Hardyston Township |
| 1999 | Richard Decker | Green Township |
| 1998 | Frank Steinberg | Hopatcong |
| 1997 | T. Donald Drake | Stanhope |
| 1996 | Phillip Crabb | Franklin |
| 1995 | Robert Mooney | Andover Borough |
| 1994 | Allen Wood, Sr. | Branchville |
| 1993 | Louis A. Cecchini | Sussex |
| 1992 | Robert "Whitey" Teets | Newton |
| 1991 | William "Bud" Decker | McAfee |
| 1990 | Thomas "Tink" Washer | Ogdensburg |
| 1989 | Steve Raye | Colesville (Wantage Twp.) |
| 1988 | Andy Jorgensen | Stillwater |
| 1987 | Mike Terwilliger | Frankford Township |
| 1986 | William Hunt | Lafayette |
| 1985 | Robert Sipley | Andover Township |
| 1984 | Charles McMickle | Hamburg |
| 1983 | Frederick Reimer | Pochuck Valley |
| 1982 | Andrew J. Morgan | Sparta |
| 1981 | Don Bogardus | Hopatcong |
| 1980 | Ralph D. Ball, Jr. | Franklin |
| 1979 | Wesley Hendershot | Andover Borough |
| 1978 | Albert Davenport | Branchville |
| 1977 | Charles Miller | Sussex |
| 1976 | Richard Horsefield | Newton Kittatinny H&L |
| 1975 | Robert Hardy | Ogdensburg |
| 1974 | William Frank | Beemerville (Wantage Twp) |
| 1973 | Clifford Rushing | Cranberry Lake |
| 1972 | William Plotts | Lafayette |
| 1971 | James Insinga | Andover Township |
| 1970 | Morris Decker | Hamburg |
| 1969 | Edwin Kantenwein | Pochuck Valley |
| 1968 | William Castimore | Sparta |
| 1967 | Robert Coulsen | Hardyston Township |
| 1966 | Ralph Shotwell | Green Township |
| 1965 | Harry Walker | Hopatcong |
| 1964 | Charles Leavey | Stanhope |
| 1963 | George S. Labance | Franklin |
| 1961-1962 | Charles Cornine | Andover Borough |
| 1960 | Ralph Clifford | Branchville |
| 1959 | Luke Sceza | Sussex |
| 1958 | William Poyer | Newton Co. 2 |
| 1957 | William Lozaw | Ogdensburg |
| 1956 | Wilbur Hunt | Lafayette |
| 1955 | Earl Dolan | Hamburg |
| 1954 | George Van Sickle | Beemerville (Wantage Twp) |
| 1953 | Andrew Devore | Newton Co. 3 |
| 1952 | Leo Osborne | Franklin |
| 1951 | Harold Rowan | Stanhope |
| 1950 | Kenneth Mills | Sparta |
| 1949 | E. Snook | Vernon |
| 1948 | Walter C. Mooney | Andover Borough |
| 1947 | Frank Urban | Branchville |
| 1946 | William Space | Sussex |
| 1945 | A. J. McConnell | Newton Patrol |
| 1944 | James M. Banghart | Newton Co. 2 |
| 1943 | Clarence Chamberlain | Ogdensburg |
| 1942 | Floyd Tidaback | Lafayette |
| 1941 | J. G. Coleman | Hamburg |
| 1940 | George O. Eagles | Newton Co. 3 |
| 1939 | Ralph W. Walters | Franklin |
| 1938 | Charles O. Rafer, Sr. | Hopatcong |
| 1937 | N. A. Woodruff | Stanhope |
| 1936 | Maurius H. Bataille | Sparta |
| 1935 | Lester McPeat | Andover Borough |
| 1934 | Sam Silverman | Branchville |
| 1932 - 1933 | Tom Trudgeon | Sussex |
| 1930 - 1931 | James C. Hyde | Ogdensburg |
| 1928 - 1929 | Doc J. G. Coleman | Hamburg |
| 1925 - 1927 | I. J. Kean | Newton |
| 1920 - 1925 | Rutherford T. Layton | Franklin |
Past Secretaries
| 2014 - Present | Cheryl (Rome Delea Thom) Raperto | Sandyston Township |
| 2013 (July - December) | Ashley (Delea) Frato | Branchville |
| 2013 (Jan. - June) | Charles Thom | Newton |
| 1993 - 2012 | Cheryl (Rome Delea) Thom | Sandyston Township |
| 1976 - 1993 | Peter Halke | Newton |
| 1975 | Keith Rowe | Ogdensburg |
| 1974 | Niel DeYoung | Beemerville |
| 1973 | Robert MacNeill | Cranberry Lake |
| 1972 | Wilbur Hunt | Lafayette |
| 1971 | Ivan McKechnie | Andover |
| 1970 | August Vinhage | Hamburg |
| 1969 | Fred Reimer, Sr. | Pochuck Valley |
| 1968 | John T. Dunn | Sparta |
| 1967 | James Shaw | Hardyston Township |
| 1966 | Samuel White | Green Township |
| 1965 | Stewart Simmons | Hopatcong |
| 1964 | Stanhope | |
| 1963 | Donald L. Kovach | Franklin |
| 1961 - 1962 | Wesley Hendershot | Andover Borough |
| 1960 | Branchville | |
| 1959 | Richard Ryker | Sussex |
| 1958 | H. Harris | Newton #2 |
| 1957 | William Washer | Ogdensburg |
| 1956 | LeRoy Post | Lafayette |
| 1955 | John Yanish | Hamburg |
| 1954 | L.B. Hulbert | Beemerville |
| 1953 | Walter Green | Newton # 3 |
| 1952 | Warren Walters | Franklin |
| 1951 | Charles Leavy | Stanhope |
| 1950 | Donald Bataille | Sparta |
| 1949 | Leon Houghtaling | Vernon |
| 1948 | Earle J. Seeley | Andover Boro |
| 1947 | Douglas M. Roy | Branchville |
| 1946 | Ryneer Huffman | Sussex |
| 1945 | J. Linn Lewis | Newton Patrol |
| 1944 | Ernest Harris | Newton # 2 |
| 1943 | Harry Slack | Ogdensburg |
| 1942 | Spencer Stopp | Lafayette |
| 1941 | Emmitt W. Johnson | Hamburg |
| 1940 | Frank Nickles | Newton # 3 |
| 1939 | Robert C. Shelton | Franklin |
| 1938 | Harry Soffel | Hopatcong |
| 1937 | Fred A. Shay | Stanhope |
| 1936 | Lewis B. Hammell | Sparta |
| 1935 | Ernest M. Seeley | Andover Boro |
| 1934 | Victor Boglioli | Branchville |
| 1932 - 1933 | L. H. Bahney | Sussex |
| 1930 - 1931 | Charles A. Newman | Ogdensburg |
| 1928 - 1929 | Hamburg | |
| 1926 - 1927 | Newton | |
| 1920 - 1925 | Vivian O. Walters | Franklin |
Past Treasurers
| 2021 - Present | Michael Streeter | Newton |
| 1999 - 2021 | T. Donald Drake | Stanhope |
| 1988 - 1999 | William A. Hunt | Lafayette |
| 1982 - 1987 | Ralph B. Ball, Jr. | Franklin |
| 1961 - 1981 | Raymond Frantz | Green Township |
| 1950 - 1960 | George S. Labance | Franklin |
| 1931 - 1960 | Perry L. Moyse | Franklin |
| 1930 | Ralph W. Walters | Franklin |
| 1920 - 1929 | Perry L. Moyse | Franklin |
Past Assistant Treasurers
| 2021 - Present | Charles Kazella | Hamburg |
Past Assistant Secretaries
| 2022 - Present | Carla Crawn | Sussex |
Past Chaplains
| 2011-Present | Chaplain: Rev. Carl F. Lazzaro | Fredon Township |
| 2016 - Present | Assistant Chaplain: Harrison Thompson | Sussex |
| 2022 - President | Assistant Chaplain: Pastor Wade Abbott | Sussex |
| 2016 - 2022 | Assistant Chaplain: William Drum | Franklin |
| 1982-20110 | Father John J. Quinlan | Our Lady of Mount Carmel, Swartswood |
| 1971-1981 | Rev. Carl Luthman | Lafayette |
| 1956 | Father Thomas | |
| 1952-1971 | Rev. John T. Kheul | Hamburg |
| 1949-1950 | Rev. Harold Blackwell | Andover |
| 1949-1950 | Rev. Aubrey Alsobrook | Andover |
| 1946 | Rev. Joseph Keeper | Sparta |
| 1945 | Rev. M. P. Seeger | Franklin |
| 1942-1950 | Rev. Henry Bowen | Stanhope |
| 1942-1945 | Rev. Stephen Palmer | Sparta |
| 1936-1941 | Rev. A. H. Darby | Hamburg |
| 1930-1935 | C. A. McPeak | Hopatcong |